Glossary entry

English term or phrase:

corporal vs physical punishment

English answer:

see explanation

Added to glossary by Kardi Kho
Feb 10, 2004 00:52
20 yrs ago
4 viewers *
English term

corporal vs physical punishment

English Law/Patents Human Resources code of conduct
What is the difference between corporal and physical punishment in the following context:

We will not condone any type of harassment, abuse, corporal, mental or physical punishment by a business partner or an employee.

I thought they were completely synonymous; it seems that I was wrong.

Any input will be much appreciated.
Thanks.

Responses

+9
58 mins
Selected

possible slight difference

I can think of one difference, although it's hard to relate to the corporate environment.
But within a school for instance, the I would say corporal punishment (now generally not permitted) would involve actually physically striking the body of the 'offender' - from slapping the wrist through to an actual caning or slippering.
Physical punishment could just be being made to do 100 press-ups, or running round the playing field 5 times, or standing on your head for 30 minutes - do you see what I mean.
However, like I say, while I can see a difference, I can't really relate either type of punishment to a corporate situation!
Peer comment(s):

agree cheungmo
19 mins
agree John Fenz : Seems to get the difference exactly right. Corporal would be any kind of punishment that might leave scar tissue, and physical anything that might cause physical discomfort (sleep deprivation, thirst, hunger)
2 hrs
agree Alex Zelkind (X)
3 hrs
agree LJC (X)
6 hrs
agree lindaellen (X)
6 hrs
agree Gareth McMillan : Good explanation.
7 hrs
agree jerrie
8 hrs
agree Armorel Young : very hard to see how corporal punishment relates to a work situation - usually only associated with schools or institutions for offenders
8 hrs
agree Matthew Fagan
9 hrs
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanks all for your comments!"
-1
11 mins

sloppy English can you ask the client to clarify?

My guess: sloppy English

corporal punishment and physical punishment ARE similar.

However physical harassment could be different from corporal punishment, say to pick a ridiculous example slapping the hands of employees who misbehave.

first the kinds of harassment not tolerated
any type of harassment, abuse, corporal,

then the kinds of punishment or retaliation
mental or physical punishment

by whom
by a business partner or an employee.
Peer comment(s):

disagree Gareth McMillan : IMO very different. Corporal punishment is usually an administered form of punishment, laid down in some way. Physical punishment can be simply forcing someone to over-work or over exert themselves to a point of physical pain.
8 hrs
how is that relevant to the context where harassmament is also mentioned?
Something went wrong...
+9
57 mins

see below

corporal has something to do with direct punishment on the body, like beating or slashing

physical can be something you force somenone to do, like to kneel for a long time.
Peer comment(s):

agree cheungmo
20 mins
merci
agree Rajan Chopra
1 hr
merci
agree Tony M : Yes, absolutely!
4 hrs
agree sarahl (X) : expérience personnelle Linou? :)
4 hrs
les deux mon general
agree LJC (X)
6 hrs
agree lindaellen (X)
6 hrs
agree Gareth McMillan : Agree if you mean "lashing"- slashing is cutting by swiping violently with , say, an open razor. Used to be a favourite tequnique of Glasgow gangs used in street fighting. Very fast and nasty- I've seen it done, but never to an employee!
7 hrs
yes, sorry, lashing, I didn't look it up
agree Matthew Fagan
9 hrs
agree Mario Marcolin : definitely!
10 hrs
merci a tous
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search